BEST pizza on the beach! 3/10/2007 Reviewer: Corey from North Canton, OH
Beware, waits for this pizza (esp on the popular nights) can take 2 to 4 hours they are THAT popular. Don't go and order from someone else because trust me, it won't be worth it. Great pizza, HUGE portions and friendly staff can all be found at Cosmo's.
Best pizza in the area 11/20/2006 Reviewer: Tim-OBX from KDH, NC
Great for lunch too. Stop in for a slice. Great pizza
Under New Management 8/18/2006 Reviewer: Sal from Reinholds, PA
Pizza was always good. Now it's very good. Best pizza in OBX hands down...
if "tomato pie" from new jersey is so good.... 5/30/2006 Reviewer: Duck Boy from Washington, D.C.
then why dont you just stay up in new jersey and make both of us happy.
Good Pizza, Friendly Staff 7/19/2005 Reviewer: NEW from Athens, GA
I couldn't agree more with Neil and Robert. Grew up on the Jersey shore and was transplanted to the South. Have been looking for great pizza ever since. Cosmo's is good pizza not great but good. The staff is very friendly and makes you feel at home. We had three pizzas with different toppings and all were good. But I'm still looking for that large slice of pizza that you can fold over.
Just Like Home 1/30/2004 Reviewer: Neil from Caldwell, NJ, USA
First of all, Robert is right about New Jersey making a better "Tomato Pie" than New York. Anyone that's ever been to Maruca's in Seaside Heights knows that. On the OBX, Cosmo's is a breath of fresh air. We ate at the Southern Shores location. The owners both come from restaurant families (he's from NY, she's from NJ), and they have done an admirable job of replicating NY/NJ style pizza crust under impossible circumstances. The sauce is actually made out of tomatoes (see my review of Stone Oven "Pizza"), and the toppings are as close to authentic as you will find outside the NY/NJ area.
I hate to sound so chauvanistic about NY/NJ pizza, but hey -- the first pizzeria in America was Lombardi's in Manhattan, so everything else is just a pretender. Cosmo's is well worth a visit.
Clearly the best on Northern Banks..... 11/16/2003 Reviewer: Robert from The Jersey Shore
.....but I can only give it 2 stars based on my pizza rating scale. If it was a OBX Pizza rating I would give it 5 stars. Being from New Jersey, (which, for your information makes a better tomato pie than New York City), I am extremely critical of my pizza and I have found nothing on OBX that comes anywhere close to the pizza made in the Northeast. With that said however, when I need a pizza fix, and that does occur probably two times during our two week stay, I travel up to the Corolla Light Village Shops to Cosmo's. Cosmo makes the best pie on the Northern Banks and maybe the entire OBX IMHO. I have also had thier calzones and strombolis, but would not recommend either if you know what one should taste like. If you don't know, you will probably enjoy them. Bottom line is when you crave a tomato pie "go to Cosmo". The price seems fair for an OBX pizza but wow, a large at Cosmo's is about $4-$6 more than here in New Jersey. The place is small, with few tables and a pleasing but nondescript decor. Beer and wine is available.
Reminder: The reviews are the opinion of the poster, and are not necessarily shared by the ownership of OBX Connection. The poster is solely responsible for the content of their review.
(
BEST pizza on the beach! 3/10/2007
Clearly the best on Northern Banks..... 11/16/2003