As a Charterboat owner and operator I find your post very interesting in several ways. I welcome your points/questions and hopefully I can give not only you but others some good guidance "Right From The Horse's Mouth".
Salvo - as some already said you can go North or South to charter a boat. Hatteras vs. the three Marinas in the Oregon Inlet area can offer different fishing at certain times and different pricing. Hatteras usually will have slightly cheaper Inshore Boats.
Small Boat - A family of 5 with children should not have a "Small Boat" under most conditions. When I talk small boat, I'm talking the many Outboard Powered Charter/Guide Boats ranging from 21 feet to even 30 feet. Most have no room to move around, no shelter to get out of weather, generally no mate to help and possibly very limited head (restroom) facilities. These boats do serve a very good purpose under certain conditions and catch a lot of fish and are significantly cheaper. Most only do Inlet and Sound fishing. Your best experience will be on a full sized boat with Captain and Mate.
Dogs - Okay, lets talk Dog. I'm a Dog owner and very attached, but on my boat NO DOGS. There probably will be some that will allow a dog, but probably not allow it in the cabin. My personal experience, way back, with Dogs on a charter ranged from stressed out Barking Dogs, to Sea Sick Dogs, to significant P & P(Got it), to owners who did not care for their dogs, to dog jumping over to retrieve a fish. You have to research this.
Price - I'm not sure of pricing down in Hatteras. The Northern Marinas, OBX Marina in Wanchese, Oregon Inlet Fishing Center and Pirates Cove have different pricing. Both OIFC and PC are basically price fixed, all the boats charge the same price for the same trip. OBX Marina has prices set by each boat and slightly cheaper than the other two. Here's some average prices:
Half Day (4 Hours) $575 to $700
Half Day (6 Hours) $775 to $900
Offshore (Gulfstream) $1800 to $2200
Small Open Boat Sound (4 Hours) $375 to $500
Family Friendly - I left the best to last. Very, very personal question totally based on each persons experience. I'm sure you will get manyAll boats welcome children. Captain and Mates have a wide range of experience, ages and attitudes. Some are very focused on Fish "Catching" and might not give the children the attention they need to have a good experience. Small open boats without a mate can be challenged with beginners or people that need a lot of help. Will the mate spend time with the party explaining the target fish, fishing locations, fishing methods, possibly explain the sights, boat and possibly allow the children on the bridge to watch the fish finder etc. All goes into a great experience. It goes beyond that too. There are a lot of "Cowboys" out there, what is their weather cancellation policy. Rain doesn't hurt but Sea and Wind conditions sure do. If you can't stand you're not going to have fun.
Okay I can go on and on. With my 50 plus years in the business I have a lot to say, but "I promise not to make your ears bleed" If you want to send me a PM please do. I'm very proud of the Outer Banks Fishing Possibilities, whether it be Boat, Pier or Surf.
LikeQuoteFlag