Lisa's Pizza - Outer Banks Restaurants
Lisa's Pizza Contact Information & Reviews
Lisa's Pizza Reviews - Add A New Review
Rating: Usually order multiple times during our week's vacay 7/29/2018
Reviewer: fjaco68

Good Italian food - I love their sauce. Fried mushrooms is a must have for our group. They deliver - which is an added bonus for us.

Rating: Recommended 8/26/2015
Reviewer: SUPOLE

Our rental company recommended Lisa's and, since it was right down the street, we did. So glad they did! Our group ordered eggplant parm, calzone, lasagna, subs, onion rings. We called in the order (nice to keep menus in the rental!). They are super busy and the food is why. Members of the group had lunch also. Convenient location and good food. Be patient.

Rating: Average 7/18/2014
Reviewer: Tay

Atmosphere is nice and the people are very accommodating. This pizza was just okay for us, i.e. I'm not going to say this was the greatest pizza on earth. My wife's calzone was okay, but nothing to get excited about either.

Rating: All Good! 7/17/2013
Reviewer: Buckeye

Delicious, Fast, reasonable prices. Only ordered carry out. Dining area is a little small, as many carryout pick up customers as dine-in dinners. Very busy-translates into very good pizza. Have not ordered other menu items but would assume it's all good.

Rating: A must stop for us 2/5/2013
Reviewer: Md.Chas

Good Pizza, good subs, nice little bar, friendly service. We usually stop here as soon as we arrive, get a pizza or some subs to eat as we unpack.

Rating: Yessiree! 10/5/2010
Reviewer: MM

Delicious tangy sauce and crispy shell. Lightning-fast delivery, too, if you choose to go that route. Nice folks too!

Rating: Good little pizzeria, but there are better on H.I. 5/4/2010
Reviewer: JPritch

Tried Lisa's for the first time recently. I'd rate the pizza/food 3-stars, but gave an overall 4-star review because of the friendly staff and overall atmosphere of the restaurant. The pizza was run of the mill, about what I could get at any pizza shack in any town, and not good enough to convince me to make a special trip in the future to get it again. The only other pizza I've tried on Hatteras Island that is worthy of a special trip would be Topper's in Avon. I don't think you can go wrong with Lisa's though if you're staying in Rodanthe and want a quick bite to eat.

Rating: Yummm 10/23/2009
Reviewer: yancy

Great pizza ....great food...great service. They even delivered 30 pizzas a few years back for a wedding rehearsal party

Rating: Eh? Just so-so 9/28/2009
Reviewer: Junebug

We stopped here once on our way to Waves. We'd made it the entire way from Alexandria, VA without hitting any traffic. Then we got stuck in traffic from an accident on 12! Luckily we were next to Lisa's so we decided to pull over and have a bite while we waited for traffic to clear. It was a good way to avoid sitting in the car, but the actual food was not very memorable. I'm a self proclaimed "foodie" and can just about tell you everything I've ever tried at any restaurant.....but for the life of me I can't remember what I had at Lisa's. I guess that speaks volumes.

Rating: Great Pizza 9/28/2009
Reviewer: Linda R.

We wre there in June 2009 and ordered 8 pizzas which were all great and fast service. We will be going back.

Rating: YUCK! 9/25/2008
Reviewer: M&M

Oh no, I would never eat here again! The pizza is equivalent to what they sevrve at Chuck -e-cheese. I would not recommend this place at all. We tried another place down the road another night, and there pizza, while procey, was phenominal. Lisa's pizza SUCKS!

Rating: fantastic pizza 9/4/2008
Reviewer: Linda Hixson

We love their pizza, We have been to the outer banks quite a few times and we always head to Lisa's even if we are staying in Corolla or Duck. Our son is getting married in June 09 and he wants to go to Lisa's pizza for his Rehearsal dinner.

Rating: Better than most 2/28/2008
Reviewer: E

Great Greek Pizza

Rating: Best Pizza South of NYC 9/22/2007
Reviewer: Dan

I am voting again, because the person below (also from NYC) who didn't like the pizza posted twice.

Rating: Best Pizza South of NYC 9/22/2007
Reviewer: Dan

I have been going to Lisa's on my vacations for 20 years, and all I can say is that they have phenominal pizza. I am from NYC, but I still look forward to having their pizza every time I visit. There is a reason this place is mobbed for dinner during the peak season. I would even go as far to say that they *consistently* make the best pizza, period.

Rating: good pizza 9/12/2007
Reviewer: pittguy25

i stopped right before they closed for the year so they were out of many things. pizza was good though

Rating: One step above frozen pizza 6/1/2007
Reviewer: Vinny Gabbagool

We've been coming to OBX for 20+ years and we currently own a house in Rodanthe, the quality does not seem as good as it was a couple of years ago. The pizza looked like it was pulled from a freezer and the meatballs and broccoli looked tiny and sickly.

Rating: One step above frozen pizza 6/1/2007
Reviewer: Vinny Gabbagool

We've been coming to OBX for 20+ years and we currently own a house in Rodanthe, the quality does not seem as good as it was a couple of years ago. The pizza looked like it was pulled from a freezer and the meatballs and broccoli looked tiny and sickly.

Rating: The best on the beach 3/7/2007
Reviewer: Norma

We've been going to Lisa's at least 3 times during our week's stay! Great little place with fantastic staff and service! The girls have always been so great with my son, nieces, & nephews we take with us and worked to suit their individual pickiness. Food is always fresh and tasty and definitely in the budget.

Rating: Lisa's ROCKS! 3/7/2007
Reviewer: J.T.

I'm 11 and been going to Lisa's my whole life! It is the best pizza on the island! I even eat the fried brocholli with ranch dressing. I recommend everybody try it!

Rating: We liked our dinners 10/12/2006
Reviewer: ohplease

We had the fried mushrooms, calzone and a sub. All were quite good and fresh. The kids grilled cheese meal was good and the fries were very good.

Rating: Pretty good 10/12/2006
Reviewer: Mary

Stopping here on the way to Avon makes sense, good pizza and a friendly atmospher.

Rating: Worth trying 7/30/2006
Reviewer: Dave F

Goog pizza but not the best on OBX. Definately worth a try if you are staying in the Rodanthe area.

Rating: Best stop for Lunch 6/12/2006
Reviewer: Mike

Stopped in on our way to Avon and again for dinner one night during the week. Great pizza and service. Make sure you stop there!!!

Rating: You've got to be kidding me! 6/10/2006
Reviewer: Julie

The pizza seemed like a generic frozen pizza you would get at the super market. My son ordered fried chicken fingers which were passable but what is so funny is that my daughter ordered a chicken sub and it was the same deep fried chicken fingers on a soft bland hero shaped roll. Then to top it off I ordered chicken parm with spaghetti and yes you guessed it cut up chicken fingers on a bed of dried out pasta topped with sauce and mozzarella. It was actually pretty funny if not very tasty!

Rating: pizza 11/30/2005
Reviewer: M B

Real good pizza

Rating: Best Pizza 2/2/2005
Reviewer: Hattears Bound

Definitely the best pizza on Hatteras Island and their other food is excellent too. They also have a bar. Very friendly staff.

Rating: Consistently good 10/25/2004
Reviewer: JennyK

We always order pizza our first night to put off going to the Food Lion in Avon. Lisa's delivers even when it requires climbing over a post-Isabel dune to get to your house.

Rating: Great place to stop on the way to Avon 10/24/2004
Reviewer: Leon

We ate lunch on our way to Avon in Sept of 2004. Excellet pizza and subs, friendly service and good value. We will be returning every year on the way to our rental.

Rating: Simply the best pizza 5/21/2004
Reviewer: SAS

Wonderful pizza. Some of the best!!!

Rating: Great food 11/28/2003
Reviewer: Rob

Had take out pizza. One of the best I've ever had. Prices were what I expected, and this place knows how to make a good pizza! If you're in the area and looking for a good pie, you'll find it here.

Rating: #1 Pizza 11/17/2003
Reviewer: Belle1952

Great pizza. Friendly service. One of our have-to eating spots on every trip to the Outer Banks.