New York Pizza Pub - Outer Banks Restaurants
New York Pizza Pub Contact Information & Reviews

New York Pizza Pub


Leave A Review

2217 S. Croatan Hwy
Nags Head, NC 27959

New York Pizza Pub Reviews - Add A New Review
Rating: Great pizza 9/1/2015
Reviewer: beachlovin

We always stop here during our week in OBX. The pizza never disappoints. We ordered the meatza pizza and added bacon and it was delicious.

Rating: As authentic as you can get on the Banks 7/23/2011
Reviewer: Jason

This pizza is really good and as authentic New York as you will get for this area- I recommend take out as the dining service has never really been outstanding. The owner, however, is really nice and from NYC. Why wouldn't you went to eat some pizza out on the deck watching the waves anyway?

Rating: Has Gone Downhill 3/28/2011
Reviewer: Ohioobxer

Pizza is just OK. Will not be back.

Rating: Great pizza, awful pasta 10/26/2009
Reviewer: Melissa

The first time I went I had the four cheese pizza and everyone in my group agreed it was some of the best pizza they'd ever had. However, on my second visit I had chicken parmesan and my bf had fettuccine alfredo and both were really bad. I didn't even eat much of it and ended up swinging by burger king on the way home.

Rating: We enjoyed it 9/28/2009
Reviewer: Junebug

Only went there once, probably 10 years ago. It seemed OK. I don't remember hating it.

Rating: Nothing Special 9/28/2009
Reviewer: JP

Heard alot of good reviews around the web, so decided to try it out. I was super hungry after an all-day fishing trip, so I ordered a ton of items off the menu. Nothing really blew me away. I've had better at other places. I would never steer anybody away from there, since it was ok, but just don't expect too much.

Rating: New York Pizza Pub Server (Steve) Is A Thief 9/9/2007
Reviewer: Sherri Clendenin

I purchased carryout at New York Pizza Pub on 9/6/07 and Steve was the cashier. I ordered a small spaghetti and a small lasagna, both of which were inedible (sour spoiled taste) and had to be tossed. The total, with tax and all, was $29.60. Since it was carryout and so expensive, I didn't leave a tip (I crossed through the tip area on receipt and wrote in $29.60 for the total). However, my on-line credit card statement shows Steve added a $6.00 tip. I'm in process of trying to get manager to credit my credit card and also disputing it with my credit card company (I have copy of receipt). And food was awful!!!

Rating: Pizza was delicious! 6/30/2007
Reviewer: Dawn

But I ordered a mudslide & it was *not* a mudslide. I'm a chocolate addict & no chocolate was put into my drink.

Rating: Blah 4/11/2007
Reviewer: Rob

Had their take out pizza.
Still looking for a good pizza place off season in the KH to NH area.

Rating: best place i've ever been. period. 3/15/2007
Reviewer: Kels

Ok listen I've been to the outer banks about 23987432 times and this place has the BESST wings i've ever had! My family and friends go atleast 2-3 times everytime we're down-- they're awesome!

Rating: Excellant pizza 7/30/2006
Reviewer: Dave F

We love the pizza at this place. We always make sure we eat here once or twice every trip. The service is usually pretty bad so be ready for that. The pizza usually makes it worth the bad service.

Rating: Enjoyed the pizza! 9/14/2005
Reviewer: Dawn

We really enjoyed the pizza this visit. Also liked the fact that it is kid-friendly. The only thing that I did not like was that we requested non smoking and were seated in a both next to the bar where people were smoking.

Rating: Best Pizza On OBX 1/20/2005
Reviewer: Ken

What more can I say. There is NO reason to try another place. Service is spotty, you might want to stick to take-out.

Rating: not bad 1/17/2005
Reviewer: corey

pizza is simple but good.

Rating: Update-2004 4/19/2004
Reviewer: Rob

Went again this year and probably won't go back.
Our waitress was unprofessional, bringing out on entree 15 minutes before everyone else's, and placing a wrong order for another. Attempted to serve wrong entree even after we cancelled the order.
Toys are gone too.
Food was good, but not as much of a value as before. Difficult to enjoy given the problem with the service.
Since I have not experienced a consistent service issue, this visit gets two instead of one star.

Rating: Wow 11/28/2003
Reviewer: Rob

This place knows Italian food. Excellent pizzas, wonderful veal and chicken parm sandwichs. Above expectations in portion size versus price. When I went a few years ago they had a huge chest of toys for kids to play with. That extra effort was appreciated!

Rating: Good Pizza 11/17/2003
Reviewer: Lisa

The best pizza we have had on the OBX. We usually eat in the restaurant but they do take out also