Rating: GO SOMEWHERE ELSE! 7/30/2010
Reviewer: B HOU

THIS PLACE SHOULD GET HIT FOR FALSE ADVERTISING. I'M CONVINCED THAT THE PANCAKES AND BISCUITS ARE MICROWAVED AND THE EGGS WERE JUST RUBBERY. THE PRICES WERE STEEP (65.00 FOR 5 PEOPLE)! I'M NOT QUITE SURE WHAT THE DEAL WAS WITH THE WATER BUT IT WAS NOT GOOD. IN SHORT, DO YOURSELF A FAVOR AND MAKE YOUR OWN BREAKFAST OR FIND SOMEWHERE ELSE TO GO

Rating: Got sick 10/26/2009
Reviewer: Melissa

I had chicken tenders there and although they tasted really good, I was sick all night after eating them.

Rating: Cute place 9/28/2009
Reviewer: Lisa

Lunch was good as was the service. Though they weren't busy when we were there. I would return.

Rating: Pine Island Diner was so-so 10/10/2005
Reviewer: Jan & dave

We encountered slow service and not much hospitality. Food was average

Rating: pine island diner 7/31/2005
Reviewer: brad wells

amazing food but it cant hold large parties altogether they have to break you up. AMAZING BUFFALO WINGS AND BANANNA SPLITS