Rating: 
Glad They Moved! 8/18/2011
Reviewer: Shannon and Tim
We love their pizza! Been going there for years but now they are even closer to the house we rent! They are the BEST!!!
Rating: 
Horrible 7/12/2011
Reviewer: Nicole
This place is a piece of crap. I ordered a pizza for delivery from them and i never got it. After waiting over an hour i call them and they say "Oh ya! the guy couldnt find your house so you can come get it. we cant send him back out cuz we need him to much. im sorry" i was so mad, hello? dont i matter too? so i forgot that place and went to pizzaz pizza. way better. dont waist your time in this dump.
Rating: Horrible 7/12/2011
Reviewer: Nicole
This place is a piece of crap. I ordered a pizza for delivery from them and i never got it. After waiting over an hour i call them and they say "Oh ya! the guy couldnt find your house so you can come get it. we can send fim back out cuz we need him to much. im sorry" i was so mad, hello? cont i matter too? so i forgot that place and went to pizzaz pizza. way better. dont waist your time in this dump.
Rating: Great Move! 5/18/2011
Reviewer: Laura
I love the Pizza Guy! So glad you got a bigger place in Monteray Plaza!!
Pizza is GREAT!
Rating: This is absolutely a WOW pizza 10/12/2010
Reviewer: George
I had my fair share of pizzas but this was top of the line. It is worth the price. The take-out pizza never made it home and we are going for more tomorrow.
Rating: LOVE this pizza! 8/28/2010
Reviewer: Sharon
Our family stops by coming into town every year and as usual they don't disappoint! They really have the best pizza and subs around!
Rating: Stay away from this insane islium 8/7/2010
Reviewer: Casey's
When they make a mistake the yell and tell you to leave and never come back.
Rating: Very Tasty! 9/15/2009
Reviewer: Mike
We had their pizza when we were in Corolla for our GVG week in Sept of 08. I thought so highly of it that I drove the eight or nine miles from Duck during out June 09 vacation to get it again.
Rating: BEST PIZZA !! 9/9/2009
Reviewer: Lucy
This is by far the best pizza on the OBX!!! My family has been coming to OBX for years and we've stayed all along from Hatteras to Corolla. We love pizza and we love this place! Delivery is fastest also!
Rating: BEST PIZZA!!! 8/13/2009
Reviewer: Josie
We have been coming to Corolla for years and we have always eaten here because it's closest to Pine Island where we stay. A few years ago it was just about convenience and pizza for the kids. The pizza was ok. Now since the new owners have taken over it's all about the pizza! It's great and we're from NY where the best pizza places are! We will gladly keep coming here for as long as we vacation in Corolla.
Rating: Quick Delivery-Friendly Service-Good Pizza & Prices 4/25/2008
Reviewer: Alan F.
I think my title says it all - We had a fairly large order and it arrived within the time we were quoted - everyone was friendly - the pizzas and subs were all good and the prices were reasonable
Rating: Try it - you'll love it 4/25/2008
Reviewer: Joseph
I was in Duck for a long weekend in mid April - I ate at Pizza Guy everyday while there and enjoyed everything I ate. I tried the pizza, subs and salads. All was very good and I strongly recommend everything on the menu.
Rating: Wonderful Place to Eat 4/25/2008
Reviewer: Sandy
My kids made a meal of the appetizers and loved them all. The pizza was great. The staff was friendly. The prices were very reasonable.
Rating: Great Pizza - Good Price 4/25/2008
Reviewer: Kim
I had eaten at Pizza Guy a couple of years ago and it was ok. The new owners have definitely improved it. The pizza is great and not a bad price.
Rating: New owners...better Pizza 4/20/2008
Reviewer: OBX Bob
The Pizza Guy is being run by new owners. The pizza was much better. the staff friendly and helpful and I am looking forward to more pizza from them this summer.
Rating: New owners...better Pizza 4/20/2008
Reviewer: OBX Bob
The Pizza Guy is being run by new owners. The pizza was much better. the staff friendly and helpful and I am looking forward to more pizza from them this summer.
Rating: Worst Pizza I've Ever Eaten! 9/16/2007
Reviewer: Denise
This is the worst pizza I have ever tasted! It's so bad I walked away from the pizza to write this review because I didn't want anyone else to have to endure this supposed "pizza". Insult to injury was the fact we had to wait over an hour for it to be delivered and it was over priced!
Rating: Wanted to give it no stars 11/20/2006
Reviewer: Robert
Absolutely the worst pizza I have never eaten. In addition the "pizza" (I use the term loosely) guy had the nerve to charge in the high teens for a large pie!!! Guess I should have suspected the worst when they have American cheese listed as a topping. :0
September 2006
Rating: Not NY style pizza 8/7/2006
Reviewer: homeowner
The pizza was not very good.
Rating: 
Great for Take Out! 5/19/2006
Reviewer: Brenda
We ordered from them mostly because they're close by our vacation home. We were pleasently surprised by the freshness of the ingredients used. The pizza is a tiny bit pricey, so I gave it only 4 stars, but it wasn't any worse than what we'd have back home.
Rating: worse than chuck e cheese 2/24/2005
Reviewer: joe pro
id rather eat a frozen pizza from food lion
Rating: way too expensive 1/17/2005
Reviewer: corey
Lets say $18.99 for a large pizza. I don't think so!
Rating: OUTSTANDING ! 11/28/2004
Reviewer: BJ Fleming
I NEVER leave the Corolla area without eating here at least once! Its usually three times. The Hot Italian sub is to die for! Also the BBQ Chicken pizza w/a white sauce will have your bunch fighting over the last piece!
Closed on Sundays so plan accordingly. He even keeps a bowl of water outside for your dog if you want to eat at one of the many picnic tables outside with your friend.
Rating: 
Fast delivery 10/26/2004
Reviewer: Mary Jo
We had pizza delivered just prior to Hurricane Charlie hitting the area. Although the roads were a bit flooded, their driver got through. Not a great pizza but adequate for a quick dinner for the kids.